Most people shopping for a counsellor are looking for someone nice.

Warm voice. Soft chair. Someone who nods. Someone who won't make it awkward.

I get it. If you've finally decided to talk to somebody, the last thing you want is a fight.

But nice isn't the job. And the research on what actually makes counselling work says so pretty clearly.

What the Research Actually Measured

In 2009, a team led by psychologist Timothy Anderson looked at 25 therapists and the 1,141 clients they saw at a university counselling centre. Every client filled out a symptom questionnaire at every session, so the researchers could see whose clients actually got better, and how fast.

Then they tested the therapists. Not with a personality quiz. With a performance test.

Each therapist watched short videos of actors playing the hardest moments in a counselling room, and had to respond on the spot, as if the person were sitting across from them:

An angry client who says, flat out, "You can't help me." A silent one: "I don't know what to talk about." One who agrees with everything and just wants to be told what to do. One who blames everyone, the therapist included.

1,141
clients. The therapists who handled those hard moments best had clients who improved faster. The therapists' own rating of their social skills predicted nothing. Neither did their therapy model.

Read that again. How good a counsellor thought they were with people didn't predict results. What mattered was what they did when the session went sideways.

One more detail. Older therapists got better results too, until the researchers accounted for those hard-moment skills. The authors' read: these skills take more practice to build than standard clinical training provides.

Nice Is Not the Same as the Relationship

You've probably heard that the relationship between you and your counsellor is one of the most consistent predictors of whether counselling helps. That holds up. One review pooled 295 studies and more than 30,000 clients, and found the link held across every type of therapy it looked at (Flückiger et al., 2018).

Flückiger, Del Re, Wampold & Horvath, 2018. Psychotherapy

But "relationship" in that research doesn't mean liking each other. It's measured as three things: agreeing on what you're working toward, agreeing on how you'll get there, and the bond between you.

The bond is one of three. A counsellor can be lovely to sit with and still never land on what you actually came in to fix.

Things Go Sideways. That's Not Failure.

Researchers call it a rupture: any strain in the working relationship. You feel judged. They push something you're not ready for. You go quiet. You show up and decide to talk about the weather for fifty minutes.

It happens far more than anyone says out loud. In one small study, clients reported a rupture in 42% of sessions. Observers reading transcripts of the same sessions spotted signs of one in 77%.

Meaning: a lot of the time, something's off and nobody names it.

A review by Safran, Muran and Eubanks-Carter (2011) pooled studies that tracked whether those strains got worked through. Where they did, outcomes were better. It's a small evidence base, three studies and 148 clients, and the authors say so. But it points the same direction as Anderson's findings, and their advice to counsellors is plain: clients often hold back negative feelings about therapy for fear of how the counsellor will react, so the counsellor should watch for it and bring it up first.

Safran, Muran & Eubanks-Carter, 2011. Psychotherapy. Also reports the 42% and 77% rupture figures (Sommerfeld et al., 2008)

The job isn't to avoid the hard moment. It's to notice it and deal with it.

It's Not About Being Hard on People Either

Here's where people get it wrong the other way. "So I want a counsellor who gets in my face."

No.

In 1993, William Miller's team randomly assigned 42 problem drinkers to different counselling styles, including a directive, confrontational one. Confrontation produced more pushback, and the pushback predicted worse results a year later. Across counsellors, the more a counsellor confronted, the more the client drank. The styles didn't differ in overall drinking results. The confrontation itself tracked with worse ones.

Miller, Benefield & Tonigan, 1993. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology

Tough isn't the skill. Nice on its own isn't either. The skill is staying steady when it gets hard: not backing off, and not piling on.

Where I Learned It

Grad school taught me the research. Underground taught me the skill.

Shiftboss. Roughneck. Occupational health and safety across mining, oil and gas, and rail. In that world, telling a guy what he wants to hear instead of what's true isn't kindness. It's how people get hurt. And yelling at him doesn't work either. He just stops telling you things.

Every site I've worked runs on stop-work authority. Anyone on the crew, the greenest guy on shift included, can stop the job if something isn't right, and nobody gets punished for calling it. I've been the one who called it, on a job worth billions, with the people above me not happy about it.

So here's how I run my office:

You have stop-work authority in here.

If something I say lands wrong, call it. If we're working on the wrong thing, call it. If you think this isn't working, say "this isn't working." That's not you being difficult. It's the most useful thing you can say in the room, and it's my job to hear it without getting defensive.

And if I see you go quiet, I'm going to ask about it. Not to put you on the spot. Because that's usually where the work is.

What to Look For in a Counsellor

They check how it's going, and mean it. Not just at intake. Partway through, too.

When you push back, they get curious. Not defensive, not wounded.

They'll tell you something you don't want to hear, and they'll be decent about it.

You could both say, in one sentence, what you're working on. If neither of you can, that's the first thing to fix.

If it's not a fit, they say so, and help you find someone who is.

If you've tried counselling and it felt like a nice chat that went nowhere, that isn't proof counselling doesn't work for you. It might just be proof that nice wasn't enough.

And if you run crews, the same idea applies to your supervisors: make it safe to call it early. That's the backbone of my psychological health and safety work with industrial employers.

Working a Rotation?

I still take some industrial, FIFO and rotational workers as counselling clients: video sessions or in person in Kamloops, scheduled around your rotation. Call (778) 921-0960 or email nicholas@hoekscounselling.com for a compatibility check.

Call (778) 921-0960

Questions I Get Asked

What makes a counsellor effective?

Research points less to a counsellor's personality or therapy model and more to how they handle difficult moments in session: when a client gets angry, shuts down, or says it isn't working. In one study of 1,141 clients, the therapists who handled those moments best had clients who improved faster, while the therapists' own rating of their social skills didn't predict results.

Is it OK to tell my counsellor that therapy isn't working?

Yes. Research on alliance ruptures shows strains in the counselling relationship are common, and working through them is linked to better outcomes. A good counsellor wants to hear it and should respond without getting defensive.

Should my counsellor challenge me?

Sometimes, yes. But harsh confrontation can backfire: in one trial with problem drinkers, overall results didn't differ by style, but the more a counsellor confronted, the more clients drank a year later. What helps is honest feedback delivered steadily. Not niceness, and not toughness.

Nicholas van Sabben, RCC
Nicholas van Sabben, RCC
Registered Clinical Counsellor · Former underground miner & shiftboss · Read more →